How bad do you think Britney's vocals really are?

[TheCharmedTributes1]

Regarding Alien's leaked vocals - do you think that her voice is really that bad or it's just he media who made things seem worse as they really are? Discuss!

[How I Roll]

 

 

S T O P 

[VinceSpears]

The media is just overreacting! It's not even bad. 

[GimmeOnyx]

I swear I heard this alien recording like months ago...is news being recycled?

 

ANYWAYS while the recording wasn't anywhere near great imo, I'm never gonna hear it live sounding like that, so I don't care what she sounded like in the clip lol. I like the album version tho for sure, so the media can kiss Britney's sparkling ass

 

 

    

[The Dream]

Ι honestly think that it is good! Yes, sometimes she is off key, but that happens and it's innapropriate to judge sth that it was not meant to be heard.

She sounds almost like in the cd version!

The media are doing what they always do, haters are doing the same, but we as fans need to stand with our Britney.

We are talking about our Britney here, don't forget this

[Term of Endearment]

I personally did not like it, but then again - it was a warm up - so I can get over it. 

[ALLEYESONUS!]

She can sing on key, it's just that her voice has probably taken a lot of damage during the years. And she needs to work a little bit on her technics more.

 

And the main thing is probably that she needs to get back her confidence 

[heather]

  you should go back to exhell

[GlenCoco]

Guys srsly no bashing in here, this member is just asking nicely and this is just an disscusion ! dont be mean! 

 

 

there is a diference between beeing insecure and had a team that realy doesent force or is able to shut the media and rumors, and not beeing able to sing or cant sing! Britney can sing, i think the alien drama is just stupid, Orbit should get over alien for fucking real 

[Shadow]

The alien thing is just a warm-up so i'll vote for "the media makes it worse than it is"

But overall I don't really think of Britney as a great vocalist either, but she's not as bad as other fanbases say.

[Ënzo.]

it's not even that bad. plus, it's only a warm up

[IfYouCantTakeItThenGetBack]

I think Britney used to have a powerful voice (star search and MMC).

However, when she became famous, she started using the iconic baby voice which is not in her natural range. I feel like that could hurt her throat. She's still a good singer but we don't look at her as a singer, we see her as an entertainer.

The Alien vocals that leaked were altered, trust me.

[Britney M. Carey]

It's true that Britney's voice is not really good because of many factors but GP does make it sound 10 times worse

[Bawbbyy]

I think the Alien vocals are all the proof we need that she cannot sing. Anyone who says it's good or that truly believes it was a 'warm-up' take are just britardedly in denial. It is painfully obvious it was not a warm-up.

[Corona]

I think the Alien vocals are all the proof we need that she cannot sing. Anyone who says it's good or that truly believes it was a 'warm-up' take are just britardedly in denial. It is painfully obvious it was not a warm-up.

Where is this place you are all talking about?

[Veis]

We will see if she will sing live  

(Or maybe recording session of perfume)

[Babydoll]

 

 

S T O P 

This kind of threads need to STOP   , THIS IS A BRITNEY SPEARS FANSITE AND FORUM  , don't forget that  :bigsmile: 

[BritCR]

I think everybody is overreacting, the fans that are fans since 1998 know that Brit can sing, maybe her voice is a little damaged but she still has a good voice. Maybe she should go with a singing coach that helps her to get back her real voice (BOMTney), but i still think that she is fine, and everybody must to get over this Alien recording, it's not a big deal.. 

[David]

has everyone forgotten her break the ice and toxic recording session vocals? she is not the best nor strongest singer in the world but do we really expect Mariah Carey/Xtina vocals from our homegirl? she has a specific voice that's memorable.

[Valerie Bitch]

I personally did not like it, but then again - it was a warm up - so I can get over it. 

 

 

This, thank you. 

[Dragneel]

I hate the choices...I don't agree with either of them...

I liked the vocals, there were some weak spots here and there but for a demo or warm up or whatever it's understandable...We could just be happy we found some random demo vocals and enjoy this sole fact instead  of debating whether she can sing or not...How could you decide by a demo anyway???

[LiaLovesGodney]

I think everybody is overreacting, the fans that are fans since 1998 know that Brit can sing, maybe her voice is a little damaged but she still has a good voice. Maybe she should go with a singing coach that helps her to get back her real voice (BOMTney), but i still think that she is fine, and everybody must to get over this Alien recording, it's not a big deal..

Us fans who have stanned from the beginning know Britney has a beautiful voice. Just listen to BOMT. It's declined over the years due to (possibly) smoking, baby voice, lack of training, drinking, stress, or whatever else. It's still not that bad. Not bad at all

[BritCR]

Us fans who have stanned from the beginning know Britney has a beautiful voice. Just listen to BOMT. It's declined over the years due to (possibly) smoking, baby voice, lack of training, drinking, stress, or whatever else. It's still not that bad. Not bad at all

I think the same thing, and to be honest that Alien recording is not that bad, is just that the tabloids like to destroy Britney and write things out of proportion   

[ashley]

I think people are being overly dramatic. I mean to go as far as saying she cannot sing? How long have you been a fan?

It's obvious her voice has declined over the years which could be the result of many things. But people need to stop trying to use this to discredit her whole career.

Even singers like Mariah and xtina have lost their voice but that's another whole other topic.

[Instantfan]

Even if it is real, so what? Can you imagine how hard it must be for her to sing in the "Britney Spears" voice and stay in key, when that's not even the way she should be singing at all? Don't get me wrong, I love the iconic Britney voice, but we all know that it's not the proper way for her to sing, and has probably damaged her voice along the many years of using it. She sounded damn good in some parts and flat as hell in others, you try singing in a breathy yet nasally baby voice and tell me how you sound amazing at all times.