IS 'Why Should I Be Sad' her most revealling song?

[BadBoiRoRo]

I mean I know she had other revealing songs but this one in particular was literal ang specific ala-rapper verses. like "I sent you to vegas with a pocket full of papers". She never bothered using any figures of speech.

 

 

thoughts? :wub:

[Nelli Gaidai]

no i think maybe everytime or rebellion r her most revealing. why should i be sad is also up there tho. its a great song tbh love it 

[BadBoiRoRo]

no i think maybe everytime or rebellion r her most revealing. why should i be sad is also up there tho. its a great song tbh love it 

I never really consider rebellion until I hear it in full. desptie how obvious that its her most revealing song to date :3

[Dolce]

Idk about Everytime. It's emotionally raw but not revealing. It doesn't say anything about whwat happened in Brit/justins relationship. Yeah I do think why should i be sad is revealing

[Nelli Gaidai]

I never really consider rebellion until I hear it in full. desptie how obvious that its her most revealing song to date :3

oh but we already have the demo version tho. i dont think the original is that much different except for a different mix or melody 

[Nelli Gaidai]

Idk about Everytime. It's emotionally raw but not revealing. It doesn't say anything about whwat happened in Brit/justins relationship. Yeah I do think why should i be sad is revealing

i also always thought blur was extremely revealing 

[James]

Rebellion is still better imo.

[Dolce]

i also always thought blur was extremely revealing 

omg I totally forgot about that song! To me it sounds like a song about someone waking up in bed next to a stranger afterthey had one too many drinks and wondering if they had sex   . But it does make total sense that this is how she felt when she was going through all that mess in 2007.  :britney-agreedlol:

[M.E.]

oh but we already have the demo version tho. i dont think the original is that much different except for a different mix or melody 

 

We don't have any full versions of the song so it's impossible to judge. However, the lyrics in the snippets are very vague and could apply to multiple situations. Nothing too revealing or personal.

[Nelli Gaidai]

omg I totally forgot about that song! To me it sounds like a song about someone waking up in bed next to a stranger afterthey had one too many drinks and wondering if they had sex   . But it does make total sense that this is how she felt when she was going through all that mess in 2007.  :britney-agreedlol:

yep i do think its a bit aoub that but its on like a sad note. i think it's like her wondering how things got to here. how they got so bad and her realizing just how depressed she is and how she would let a guy use her like that. when a girl hits that point in her life, i feel like that is a rly sad place a girl could get in. must b something rly hurting her or falling apart. that defnintely describes 2007

[Nelli Gaidai]

We don't have any full versions of the song so it's impossible to judge. However, the lyrics in the snippets are very vague and could apply to multiple situations. Nothing too revealing or personal.

yes but i still think its one of the rly personal songs. even if they dont mean a lot to us or dont make sense or wtv they do to her. it is def most personal song for her. so wtv they mean to her, i still think would b considered very personal

[ALEX -II- 11O39]

I mean I know she had other revealing songs but this one in particular was literal ang specific ala-rapper verses. like "I sent you to vegas with a pocket full of papers vegetables". She never bothered using any figures of speech.

 

 

thoughts? :wub:

corrected 

[M.E.]

yes but i still think its one of the rly personal songs. even if they dont mean a lot to us or dont make sense or wtv they do to her. it is def most personal song for her. so wtv they mean to her, i still think would b considered very personal

 

Personal, yes, revealing, no.

[Nelli Gaidai]

Personal, yes, revealing, no.

oh ok i see. i think most of her songs r revealing tbh

[CIRCUS]

lol what a stupid question

 

of course it does! 

[BadBoiRoRo]

corrected 

lol, I see what you did there

[sodramatic]

it is very revealing and a beautiful song but I think Rebellion is the most revealing.

I need to go listen to WSIBS now

[Joanhs]

Yes, Pharrel wrote just out of headlines on magazines and papers, showed it to britney who then approved it. I think her approval says it all, the song is really how it was, no lies detected, and thats why I really believe that song. Blur and everything else could have been the labels choice to make it sound like this is britneys life.

[Ooh-Ooh Britney]

I think it's one of her most revealing songs, and I don't het how some people dislike it. I love it tbh :britney-agreedlol:

[WorkbitchPerfume]

Perfume is, in my opinion. Revealing and honest.

[Cheer Up Charlie]

    

  

An underrated gem. I don't understand.  

[tarotx]

It's straight out of the headlines. Just like POM. Who knows if it's actually revealing as to "this is what happened" but it captured what Britney was feeling about the subject. 

[BraveNewSeth]

Is it revealing? Yes. Is it her most revealing song? No. Someday, Everytime, Rebellion, and a few others are more revealing IMO.

[Larissa]

i am so sad that we will never hear rebellion in full. i like why should i be sad. but NOTHING will be ever reach the state of rebellion. 

in my mind the world has to hear the full song of rebellion. ...

[MakeItCoolerInHere]

It was pretty revealing at the time, with the divorce and everything. Even though the credits said she didn't write it, I'm sure she gave her input and they made the perfect song for her at the time. I really love the song and don't get the hate for it